Your watchdog for recalls, scams and product safety.

Consumer Alerts

Sentry Insurance $2.75 Million Auto Policy Settlement Could Pay New Mexico Drivers up to $25,000 or Premium Refunds After Claim Dispute

Sentry Insurance settlement notice with details about auto policy claims and premium refunds

ALBUQUERQUE, NM — Some New Mexico drivers insured by Sentry Insurance Co. and its affiliates may be eligible for money from a $2.75 million class action settlement tied to underinsured motorist claims and premium charges.

The proposed deal covers policyholders who had an underinsured motorist claim reduced by the amount paid by an at-fault driver’s insurer, as well as some customers who bought uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage during the class period. Depending on the category, eligible people could receive up to $25,000 per valid claim or an automatic partial refund of premiums.

The settlement still needs court approval, and payments will not go out until the legal process is complete.

Which New Mexico drivers may be included in the settlement

The class is divided into two groups. The first includes people with an underinsured motorist claim under a New Mexico auto policy issued by Sentry or related companies, including Dairyland Insurance Co., Peak Property and Casualty Insurance Corp., Viking Insurance Co. of Wisconsin and Sentry Select Insurance Co.

To qualify for that group, the policy had to have an effective date before Jan. 1, 2022, and the accident must have occurred between Oct. 1, 2010, and Dec. 31, 2022. Those claims also had to be reduced or offset by the amount paid by the at-fault driver’s insurer.

The second group includes New Mexico drivers who purchased or paid premiums for Sentry auto insurance with uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage during that same time period but did not have a qualifying offset claim.

How the lawsuit says Sentry handled underinsured motorist benefits

The case alleges Sentry and its affiliates did not adequately tell policyholders that under New Mexico law, underinsured motorist benefits would be reduced by what the at-fault driver’s insurer paid. Plaintiffs said that practice led to lower claim payments and premiums that they considered unfair.

Sentry has denied wrongdoing, but the company agreed to settle rather than continue litigation. The settlement is meant to resolve those allegations without a trial.

Under the agreement, $915,000 is earmarked for claims from the offset subclass. If valid claims exceed that amount, payments may be reduced on a pro rata basis.

How much money eligible class members may receive

People in the offset subclass can file a claim for up to $25,000 per valid claim, though the final amount depends on how many claims are approved. That group is the only one that must actively submit paperwork to seek payment.

Other settlement class members who only bought qualifying coverage during the class period do not need to file a claim. If the court approves the settlement, the administrator will automatically mail checks to those eligible policyholders.

The refund for that second group will be based on several factors, including the total premiums paid, the number of eligible people and the net settlement fund after costs are deducted.

What people must submit to make a claim

Offset subclass members can complete an online claim form or print a PDF version and mail it to the settlement administrator. The mailing address is Coto v. Sentry Insurance Co., Settlement Administrator, P.O. Box 2449, Portland, OR 97208-2449.

Every claimant must include the unique ID from the settlement notice. People filing online also need the PIN from that notice. The administrator will compare claims with Sentry’s records before making any payment.

Approved payments may be delivered through Zelle, PayPal, Venmo or a paper check sent to the address on file.

Key deadlines and what happens before payments go out

Anyone who wants to opt out of the settlement must do so by Dec. 24, 2026. The deadline to file a claim is Jan. 8, 2027. A final approval hearing has not yet been scheduled.

The court must decide whether to approve the agreement, and any appeals would also need to be resolved before money is distributed. That means the payout timeline remains tied to the pace of the court process.

The full settlement fund totals $2,750,000. It includes up to $916,666.67 for attorneys’ fees, up to $6,200 in expenses and a $10,000 service award for the class representative, with the rest available for eligible policyholders and other settlement costs.

Why the proposed deal matters for policyholders in New Mexico

The settlement centers on how uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage was handled in New Mexico auto policies over a period stretching from 2010 through 2022. For some drivers, the issue involved reduced claim payments after an accident. For others, it concerns whether premiums for the coverage were charged in a way that now qualifies them for a refund.

Because the eligible groups are split, the settlement does not work the same way for everyone. Some people will need to act on their own by filing a claim, while others will be paid automatically if the court signs off on the deal.

For New Mexico policyholders who think they may be included, the notice they received contains the identifying information needed to check eligibility and pursue payment.

Leave a Reply